Insurance
- 3 state
- 5 control
- 1 variable
- Lagrange cost
- fixed final time
- 2 state box
- 5 control box
- 1 variable box
- 4 path
- 4 boundary
- OptimalControl valid
- OptimalControl, scalarized valid
- JuMP valid
The insurance problem is a benchmark in optimal control inspired by health and financial economics. It consists of controlling insurance coverage, expenses, revenue, health, and utility over a fixed horizon to maximise expected utility. The system dynamics model the evolution of insurance participation, expenses, and auxiliary variables, while respecting bounds on all state and control variables. The controls represent health investments, insurance revenue, health outcomes, and utility contributions.
Mathematical formulation
The objective is to maximise expected utility:
where
State, control, and auxiliary bounds
The variables are subject to:
Initial and terminal conditions
Dynamics
with the expense transformation:
Algebraic / auxiliary constraints
These constraints encode revenue balance, health evolution, utility computation, and auxiliary relationships.
Qualitative behaviour
The optimal strategy balances insurance coverage, health investment, and expenses to maximise utility under constraints.
Revenue and health constraints link controls and states nonlinearly.
The dynamics incorporate moral hazard effects and diminishing returns on expenses.
Auxiliary variables track utility and revenue derivatives, ensuring consistent constraints.
Characteristics
Nonlinear dynamics, with an auxiliary control.
Models health insurance optimisation under ex post moral hazard and risk-sensitive utility.
Serves as a benchmark for testing constrained nonlinear OCP solvers.
References
Martinon, P., Picard, P., & Raj, A. (2018). On the design of optimal health insurance contracts under ex post moral hazard. The Geneva Risk and Insurance Review, 43, 127–155. doi:10.1057/s10713-018-0034-y Provides a theoretical framework for optimal health insurance design under moral hazard, which inspired the benchmark problem formulation.
Bocop Repository: Insurance Example. github.com/control-toolbox/bocop/tree/main/bocop Contains the implementation of the insurance optimal control problem used for testing direct transcription methods and NLP solvers.
Parameters
| Parameter | Default value | Unit | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
t0 | 0 | – | initial time |
tf | 10 | – | final time |
γ | 0.2 | – | rate at which the health H deteriorates, H = h0 − γ (t − t0)(1 − v(m)) |
λ | 0.25 | – | rate of the exponential law of the time of illness, in the density fx |
h0 | 1.5 | – | initial health level |
w | 1 | – | wealth in the revenue R = w − P + I − m − ε |
s | 10 | – | sensitivity of the utility to the revenue, U = 1 − exp(−s R) + H |
k | 0 | – | coefficient of the loss ε = k (t − t0) / (tf − t + 1) |
σ | 0 | – | loading of the premium, P = x₃(tf) with ẋ₃ = (1 + σ) I fx |
α | 4 | – | exponent of the efficacy v(m) = m^(α/2) / (1 + m^(α/2)) of the expenses |
I_l | 0 | – | lower bound of the indemnity I |
I_u | 1.5 | – | upper bound of the indemnity I |
m_l | 0 | – | lower bound of the medical expenses m |
m_u | 1.5 | – | upper bound of the medical expenses m |
h_l | 0 | – | lower bound of the control h |
h_u | 25 | – | upper bound of the control h |
R_l | 0 | – | lower bound of the revenue R |
H_l | 0 | – | lower bound of the health H |
U_l | 0 | – | lower bound of the utility U |
dUdR_l | 0.001 | – | lower bound of the marginal utility dU/dR |
P_l | 0 | – | lower bound of the premium P |
I_t0 | 0 | – | initial indemnity |
m_t0 | 0.001 | – | initial medical expenses |
x₃_t0 | 0 | – | initial value of x₃, the accumulated cost of the indemnity |
Every modeling takes other values with the keyword parameters, merged with these: insurance(backend; parameters=(t0=…,)).
Reference objective
The best objective among the solves that converged, in each modeling, on the default grid of the modeling: the modelings are independent, each has its own reference. See how the references are computed.
| Modeling | Scheme | Grid | Reference objective | Solves | Distinct solutions | Configurations agree |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| JuMP | :trapeze | 500 | -2.059213403 | 8 | 1 | yes, within 3.4e-06 |
| OptimalControl | :trapeze | 500 | -2.059213403 | 17 | 1 | yes, within 3.4e-06 |
| OptimalControl, scalarized | :trapeze | 500 | -2.059213403 | 3 | 1 | yes, within 0 |